Sunday, 21 February 2016

CRITICAL REASONING

CR Article


CR
The biggest folly that we, the students make when we are attempting this type of questions can be highlighted under the following bullets:-

· Think that by mere impulse we can solve :3

· Jump to marking the particular option just when we have agreed to a particular option which is say B, and not even bothering to read the other options :v

· Think that Critical Reasoning questions cannot be solved by logic but mere gut instincts. LOLWA

Well, I am sorry to inform you but aise nahi hoga beta :P

Lets begin:-

These are the frequently asked questions or rather the possible questions that came to my mind that a person can ask while tackling CR

1. How do we approach the questions?


Ans:-    First of all read the paragraph well. Have patience. I cannot stress how important this is when you are attempting CAT having under performed in my first attempt itself. Try and understand what the author is trying to tell. Make short notes. Perform scratch work. We will discuss on this as we proceed.

2. How many types of Critical Reasoning questions are there?


Ans:-    Well many, in a single word.  Jokes apart, you have to get these four words drilled in your head.

a) Conclusion= hence, thus, must, therefore etc

b) Premise= tree of reason for the conclusion part. ( body stem )

c) Assumptions= The basic connection that must be made. ( Read detective novels. Or watch the good old hercule poirot series . Stimulate the senses  )

d) Argument= premise and conclusion

 Eg:- I am sick. Maybe it is because I  got wet in the rain yesterday.

A basic assumption that one gets sick due to the event of getting wet must be made.

But the major types ( more or less to give you an idea ) are as follows:-

· Assumption based questions

· Conclusion based questions

· Inference based questions

· Strengthening an argument based questions

· Weakening an argument based questions

· Evaluating argument based questions

· possible completing sentence after a paragraph.

· Finding the flaw type questions

3. So how shall I proceed or go about answering the questions?


Ans:-         Keep the following points in mind

    1)  Identify assumption / strengthen / weaken the conclusion type nature of the question and paragraph

    2)  Identify the conclusion

    3)  Deduce the conclusion / get the inference

    4) Mimic the reasoning. Depending on question type you will need to use one of the following 3 METHODS

· METHOD 1: Use Venn diagrams

· METHOD 2: Use x, y, z to simply questions

· METHOD 3: Use logical operators; In questions which involve straight forward negation or conditional analysis

    5)  Resolve the paradox- Perform regular elimination checks. Write down the option A, B, C , D and E. Weigh each one against the other. Don't hurry

    6)  Identify the flaw

    7)  Repeat in your mind- There is a definite answer and I must not solve it without considering the parts of the argument and I WILL NOT let my gut instincts play a major role in choosing an option. ( This works for me. You can try it out )

Now we shall deal with each problem pattern and how to go about solving them. I have tried to pick up solutions from here and there to aid you in the thinking pattern that must be replicated each time you solve CR questions.

I) Assumption example


Q1) credits:- MBACRYSTALL

The median age in developed countries is around 42 years, meaning that half the population is below and half the population is above 42 years old. Reports provided by psychologists indicate that 63% of those who seek psychological help in developed countries are below 42 years old. Such evidence clearly indicates that in developed countries psychological problems are more common among people who are younger than 42 years.

The argument above assumes that...

A) The percentage of the population with psychological problems is not significantly higher for developed countries than for other states.

B) Among those with psychological problems in developed countries, the percentage who seek psychological help is not significantly lower for those older than 42 than it is for those younger than 42.

C) One of the primary factors contributing to the development of psychological disorders is inability to cope with excessive stress resulting from professional activity.

D) The severity of psychological disorders in developed countries among those who have not yet turned 42 is generally lower than it is among those who are 42 or older.

E) A significant proportion of those 42 or older in developed countries are retired and no longer subject to the stress associated with educational or occupational activities.

This question requires you to notice that the subject of the evidence is those who seek professional psychological help whereas the subject of the conclusion is those with psychological problems. Even though the two categories certainly overlap, it could be quite true that many of those who have problems don't seek help, and in that case, statistics about those who visit psychologists would not lead to valid conclusions about all those who need help. Look at these answer choices and see which ones help validate the argument.

A) The percentage of the population with psychological problems is not significantly higher for developed countries than for other states. The whole argument deals with developed countries, so there is no need to consider how these statistics relate to those in less developed countries-Irrelevant.  

B) Among those with psychological problems in developed countries, the percentage who seek psychological help is not significantly lower for those older than 42 than it is for those younger than 42. Correct. If a lot more of those who are 42+ and troubled simply don't go to see a psychologist, then it could be that an equal or higher percentage of 42+ citizens have problems but just don't seek help. Choice B must be assumed if the conclusion is to be valid.  

C) One of the primary factors contributing to the development of psychological disorders is inability to cope with excessive stress resulting from professional activity. This choice is irrelevant to the conclusion and therefore cannot support its validity.

D) The severity of psychological disorders in developed countries among those who have not yet turned 42 is generally lower than it is among those who are 42 or older. The argument is concerned with psychological disorders in general, so the relative severity of such disorders is out of scope.

E) A significant proportion of those 42 or older in developed countries are retired and no longer subject to the stress associated with educational or occupational activities. Irrelevant-true or not, this assumption does not affect the conclusion of the argument.

The correct answer is B.

II) Strengthening Example


Q2) credits:- GMATCLUB

The postal service is badly mismanaged. Thirty years ago, first-class letter delivery cost only three cents. Since then, the price has increased sevenfold, with an actual decrease in the speed and reliability of service.

All of the following would tend to weaken the conclusion of the argument above EXCEPT:

a.The volume of mail handled by the postal service has increased dramatically over the last thirty years.

b.Unprecedented increases in the cost of fuel for trucks and planes have put severe upward pressures on postal delivery costs.

c.Private delivery services usually charge more than does the postal service for comparable delivery services.

d.The average delivery time for a first-class letter three decades ago was slightly longer than it is today.

e.The average level of consumer prices overall has increased fourfold over the last thirty years.

Reviewing Answer Choices

a. The volume of mail handled by the postal service has increased dramatically over the last thirty years.

This would seem to excuse the poor service/price because the service has had to overcome a massive increase in volume.

b. Unprecedented increases in the cost of fuel for trucks and planes have put severe upward pressures on postal delivery costs.

This would seem to excuse the poor service/price because costs have increased dramatically.

c. Private delivery services usually charge more than does the postal service for comparable delivery services.

This would seem to excuse the poor service/price because other services are not as efficient.

d. The average delivery time for a first-class letter three decades ago was actually slightly longer than it is today.

This shows they have made improvements in service, suggesting that the postal service isn't all that bad after all.

e. The average level of consumer prices overall has increased fourfold over the last thirty years.

Since the price of postage has increased seven times over, this suggests that postal prices have increased at a rate much quicker than inflation. Thus, choice E does support the original argument, making this the correct answer.

III) weakening examples


Q3)
credits :- 800SCORE

In many pre-schools, children tend to commonly get colds before their resistance develops and the colds become much less frequent. It is clear that a child requires several colds before white blood cell concentrations rise high enough to effectively deal with colds.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens this theory?

A. Children commonly spread viruses and bacteria in a small closed environment.

B. The use of Vitamin C increases resistance to the common cold and decreases its frequency.

C. Parents stock up on cold medicine after a child gets sick that alleviate the symptoms of a cold.

D. There are many strains of the cold virus and children develop resistance to individual strains.

E. White blood cells fight infection and their production levels are stimulated by high infection levels.

Reviewing Answer Choices

A. Children commonly spread viruses and bacteria in a small closed environment.

Not Relevant

B. The use of Vitamin C increases resistance to the common cold and decreases its frequency.

Not Relevant

C. Parents stock up on cold medicine after a child gets sick that alleviate the symptoms of a cold.

This choice presents another possible reason to undermine the argument, but the medicine deals with symptoms, not the cold per se. So it is not reducing an instance of a cold, simply decreasing their symptoms (no more runny noses!).

D. There are many strains of the cold virus and children develop resistance to individual strains.

This choice suggests an alternative explanation for the apparent improvement in a child's ability to fight colds: the child simply becomes immune to individual viruses per se. So, the theory that a child's immune system needs high white blood cell concentrations isn't the case, it is an issue of exposure to certain strains. By suggesting a different causal process to explain the reduction in colds, it weakens the argument.

E. White blood cells fight infection and their production levels are stimulated by high infection levels.

This choice supports this statement, but the question asks for what weakens it.

IV) Conclusion examples


Q4) credits:- MAGOOSH

Diamond Enterprises is a store in Apisville that sells specialty luxury items.  For several years, Diamond reaped substantial profits and was considering building branch stores in nearby counties.   Stibium Industries, for several years the single largest employer in Apisville and the surrounding region, abruptly closed its plant last year, causing widespread unemployment.  Only a fraction of the former Stibium workers have found new jobs, and many of these at much lower wages.  Early this year, Diamond Enterprises has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy, citing the closure of Stibium as one of the primary causes.

Which of the following inferences is best supported by the passage?

A. Diamond Enterprises would have avoided bankruptcy if it had followed through with the plan to build branch stores during its more prosperous years.

B. Stibium's management team had a corporate account with Diamond Enterprises, and ordered several luxury items used in business meetings and to entertain prospective clients.

C. Diamond's direct competitors, in Apisville and in the surrounding region, are much larger than Diamond, and therefore benefitted substantially from the conditions that arose after Stibium closed.

D. The closure of Stibium resulted in a loss of revenue for Diamond Enterprises.

E. After Stibium Industry closed, Diamond Enterprises was the single largest employer in Apisville.

1) The credited answer is (D).  We know Diamond had high profits before Stibium closed, and we know it was close to bankruptcy after Stibium closed, citing Stibum's closure as one of the primary causes.   There, in some way, as a result of Stibium closing, Diamond lost revenue.  Consider the opposite of (D): If Stibium closed, and that caused no revenue loss for Diamond, then how on earth could Diamond cite the closure of Stibium as one of the causes of its plummet from high profits to bankruptcy?  The opposite of (D) is a scenario that makes no sense, so (D) is an unavoidable inference, very well supported.

Choice (A) is a tempting answer.  Would branches of other Diamond stores in other towns have reaped profits, enough to avoid the bankruptcy mentioned?  Perhaps.  That's certainly a plausible possibility, but we don't know for sure.  If we don't know for sure, it's not a good inference.  (A) is incorrect.

Choice (B) is way too specific in the kind of assumptions it makes.  It seems that Diamond was getting some kind of revenue from Stibium, but was it the management buying perks? or rank-and-file workers buying treats for themselves?  We don't know.  Anything that spins a highly specific story is too much to infer strictly from the information in the prompt.    (B) is incorrect.

Choice (C) makes too many assumptions - does this specialty store Diamond have direct competitors in the region? if so, are these competitors larger?  was "being larger" an advantage in the economic conditions that resulted from Stibium's closure?  There are too many things we don't know, so we can draw a clear inference.  (C) is incorrect.

Choice (E) is entirely unfounded.  We have no idea how big Diamond is, and we have no idea what other employers Apisville might have.

  (E) is incorrect.

(D) is by far the best answer.

V) Evaluate the argument examples


Q5) credits:-VERITAS

"In the past the country of Malvernia has relied heavily on imported oil. Malvernia recently implemented a program to convert heating systems from oil to natural gas. Malvernia currently produces more natural gas each year than it uses, and oil production in Malvernian oil fields is increasing at a steady pace. If these trends in fuel production and usage continue, therefore, Malvernian reliance on foreign sources [of] fuel is likely to decline soon."

Which of the following would be most useful to establish in evaluating the argument?

(A) When, if ever, will production of oil in Malvernia outstrip production of natural gas?

 (B) Is Malvernia among the countries that rely most on imported oil?

(C) What proportion of Malvernia's total energy needs is met by hydroelectric, solar, and nuclear power?

(D) Is the amount of oil used each year in Malvernia for generating electricity and fuel for transportation increasing?

 (E) Have any existing oil-burning heating systems in Malvernia already been converted to natural-gas-burning heating systems?"

The conclusion to this argument is, "Malvernian reliance on foreign sources for fuel is likely to decline soon," and the evidence is that Malvernia has plenty of natural gas and will be using natural gas for heating. Additionally, Malvernia is increasing oil production.

The correct answer to this question is the one that, when answered one way, will strengthen the argument and, when answered the other way, will weaken it. That answer choice is D, "Is the amount of oil used each year in Malvernia for generating electricity and fuel for transportation increasing?"

If the answer is "no," the conclusion is definitely strengthened. With more domestic oil production and with natural gas used for heat, if the oil used for electricity and transportation is not increasing, Malvernia's reliance on foreign sources of fuel is likely to decrease. And if the answer is "yes," more oil will be required in the future, and even with more domestic oil production, it is unlikely that the reliance on foreign oil will decrease. This is the answer that is balanced between strengthening and weakening. None of the other answer choices asks questions that could either strengthen or weaken the conclusion.

If you want to master "evaluate" questions and maximize your critical reasoning score, look for that answer choice that does not strengthen or weaken but is balanced between the two.

VI) Finding flaw examples.


1. if true type question- not hypothetical

2. Attack the assumptions.

3. Look at statistics

Q6) credits:- BEATTHEGMAT

A city plans to attract new citizens with new housing and new facilities such as parks, recreation centers and libraries. One component of the city's plans is to require that development seeking permission is to build this new housing to provide these additional facilities at no cost to the city.

Which of the following, if true, would point to a possible flaw in the city's plan?

(A) Developers would pass along their costs to the buyer; thereby raising the cost of housing units beyond the ability of likely purchasers to afford them.

(B) Light, nonpolluting industries have located in the area, offering more jobs and better-paying jobs than do the more established industries in the area.

(C) Other towns and cities nearby have yet to embark on comparable plans to attract new citizens

(D) Most developers see the extra expense of providing municipal facilities as simply one of the many costs of doing business.

(E) Studies show that purchasers of new houses, especially first-time buyers, rank recreational resources as an important factor in deciding to buy a particular house.

A. weakening and flaw. Talks about the price. ( OA )

B. No weakening or flaw

C. Irrelevant

D. No weakening or flaw

E. No weakening .

VII) Inferences examples


1. Information not given directly.

2.. Don't go on randomly guessing

3. Must be 100% true

4. Reader's point of view given impetus.

5. Eliminate options out of scope.

Q7) credits:-LSAT
Although Locke has been hailed as a giant figure in European intellectual history, his ideas were largely borrowed from his predecessors, who are now unfairly neglected by historians. Furthermore, Locke never wrote a truly great book; his most widely known works are muddy in style, awkwardly constructed, and often self-contradictory.

With which of the following would the author most likely agree?

A. Locke made use of ideas without acknowledging his predecessors as the sources of those ideas.

B. Current historians are re-evaluating the work of Locke in the light of present-day knowledge.

C. Locke's contributions to the development of European thought have been greatly exaggerated.

D. Historians should reexamine Locke's place in European intellectual history.

E.Although Locke's ideas were important, his way of expressing them in writing was sadly inadequate.

Explanation: The author makes two assertions about Locke: that his ideas were not original and that his books were not very good. On the basis of these assertions, the author concludes that Locke's reputation as an intellectual giant is undeserved. Choice (C) accurately summarizes this conclusion.

focuses on a subsidiary point, not the main idea; moreover, it makes an assumption unsupported by the passage namely, that Locke did not acknowledge the sources of his ideas.

Is wrong because although the passage clearly indicates that the author is "re-evaluating" Locke's work, it does not suggest that "current historians" in general are doing so.

This choice best expresses the point, that Locke's contributions were not original.

Is tricky because it is a good answer, but it is not the best answer. (D) implies that the author recommends that other historians re-examine Locke. Since no recommendation exists in the argument, Choice (C) is the only option.

Not addressed.

VIII) Completion type examples


Remember these words when you are solving such question:-

1. assertation

2. prediction

3. total clarity.

4. recognise the pattern. maintain the flow

Q8) credits:- GMATCLUB

Davison River farmers are currently deciding between planting winter wheat this fall or spring wheat next spring. Winter wheat and spring wheat are usually about equally profitable. Because of new government restrictions on the use of Davison River water for irrigation, per acre yields for winter wheat, though not for spring wheat, would be much lower than average. Therefore, planting spring wheat will be more profitable than planting winter wheat, since‗‗‗‗‗‗.

A. the smaller-than-average size of a winter wheat harvest this year would not be compensated for by higher winter wheat prices

B.  new crops of spring wheat must be planted earlier than the time at which standing crops of winter wheat are ready to be harvested

C.  the spring wheat that farmers in the Davison River region plant is well adapted to the soil of the region

D. spring wheat has uses that are different from those of winter wheat

E.  planting spring wheat is more profitable than planting certain other crops, such as rye

A. the smaller-than-average size of a winter wheat harvest this year would not be compensated for by higher winter wheat prices

If size of the winter harvest would not be compensated by the winter wheat prices, then farmers would incur losses. Hence the answer.

B. new crops of spring wheat must be planted earlier than the time at which standing crops of winter wheat are ready to be harvested

The choice is not explaining why planting spring wheat is more profitable than planting winter wheat. Hence the choice is incorrect.

C. the spring wheat that farmers in the Davison River region plant is well adapted to the soil of the region

-out of scope

D. spring wheat has uses that are different from those of winter wheat

-out of scope

E. planting spring wheat is more profitable than planting certain other crops, such as rye

CONTACT ME ONLINE IF YOU ARE INTERESTED IN A VERBAL COURSE. SEND ME A FRIEND REQUEST

CLANNAD AFTER STORY

Clannad After Story ( Roopayan Ghosh )


Clannad After Story
Number of episodes-22+2OVA
Genre- Drama/Romance/Fantasy/Slice of Life
Rating:- Art and Animation-9/10, Music-9.5/10, Story-10/10, Characters-10/10, Enjoyment-9.5/10(48/50)
Well this has been reviewed too many times in forums and too many good things (and a few bad ones) have been said about it. I dont know why of all these days a sudden urge came to me to review it(Its surprising I haven't done it before), but let me whet that urge. And yes I am not reviewing Season 1 just season 2. I am not a fan of season 1, for some odd reason, and started season 2 before even going halfway through season 1. While it did not deter me from enjoying the anime, it made me watch season 1 later and ended up clearing some things which unless you watch season 1 you will never get.
I will not spend much time in explaining my ratings, just that the art and animation are typical KyoAni and yet one of their best in 24 episode anime. Maeda Jun's music grows on you as you listen. I have to admit initially when I first heard the music I wasnt captivated but then I heard the OSTs as standalones it was a surreal calming experience. The voice acting of different characters were up o the mark, they portrayed the emotions of the characters clearly enough but still there is always room for improvement.
Which brings me to the story. The storyline is dramatic and often people complain overly melodramatic. So let us break the anime up into arcs. The anime starts cheerfully yet almost each episode has some melancholy in it. Sunohara's character gets some much need exposure and until graduation the few characters which lacked proper exposure in Clannad gets their time. Specially that story of the cat is one of my favourites in AS. It is so simple yet hits you right in the kokoro. I am not a pet lover at all but that did not prevent me from having a melancholic smile on my face when the episode ended. Yes the first half of CAS will ensure you have a mix of sadness and happiness and you will not ever be able to imagine what will hit you later.
The tragedy which strikes though isnt really surprising. We all knew Nagisa(the female protag) was ill and I think at the back of the mind each of the viewer gets prepared for the worst. But what makes the anime brilliant is how they portray the lives of the characters around her. Her parents, her husband and her friends. But in this arc the single greatest episode according to me is probably the interaction between the protagonist his grandma and his father. So much emotions was bundled in that episode that it almost threatens to overshadow the main flow of the story. But then you are not spared, more tragedy strikes and everything seems almost hopeless.
There is a parallel story in a parallel world shown in each episode. And I am sure most of you will be left wondering whats going on. And near the end it becomes clear. This anime was never an ordinary slice of life. It never intended to be in the first place. It was always a fantasy slice of life. From season 1. The legend of the town starts to make sense and we get to know about Nagisa's past as well. And then the miracle happens. It is here that the fandom gets split. Some people say the miracle was not needed, while others say it was beautiful. I will leave that opinion to the viewer. If you want my personal opinion I would say that the authors had planned for this from the start, they weren't intending to make a sad anime, they were intending to make an anime tinged with melancholy yet will bring a smile on your face. They wanted to make a fairytale ending. And that ending will never demean what was shown before. Because the previous episodes hit your emotions the way they intend to, they teach you the importance of bonds and family, they teach you the sadness of losing your loved ones and what they teach you most is to treasure the people close to you, because you never know what the future holds. The hero got a second chance at life, it is almost as if the authors are telling you, “Well, we hope after seeing this anime you see the people around you differently, this is your second chance. We hope you are a little bit wiser about your outlook towards life”, just like the protagonist was told.
So why did I suddenly have the urge to review it. Oh I remember now, I saw a news that a family went for a trip to Kashmir, their car got caught in an avalanche and fell into an abyss. The wife and son were dead. The father was fighting for his life at the hospital. Somehow this reminded me of Clannad after story. Yes in real life there are no miracles, no fairy tale ending. But reality is so boring aint it?



HYOUKA

HYOUKA REVIEW ( ROOPAYAN GHOSH)

Anime review:- 
Anime:- Hyouka
Number of Episodes:- 22
Genre:- Mystery/School/Romance
Rating :- Animation and Artwork:- 9/10, Music- 8/10, Story :- 7/10, Characters:- 7/10, Enjoyment -8/10(39/50)
This is the second mystery anime I watched after Gosick. While it does not repeat a very important mistake Gosick made, is it really very good? Undoubtedly its a nice addition to the mystery genre but it has its own flaws.
For starters the animation is gorgeous. Artwork is typical moe artwork of kyoani. And I have a bone to pick with this kind of artwork. The faces are still fine by the feet of people in this kind of artwork always point inwards rater than outwards and I find that really irritating. Also the multicolored eyes. It looks nice and all but they return to haunt you and its not a nice haunting. Anyway the 1st opening and 1st ED are really nice, not only as a song but the visuals as well. The later ones don't reach that heights. The in anime music is also nothing spectacular, just fine. The voice acting of Chitanda one of the MC s is irritating but that just essentially brings out her character so it gets full points for that. Houtaro the other MC's voice acting is fine, the male supporting actor has a really nice voice acting while the other ones are just average. Well basically it means you will not remember almost anything out of this anime except the japanese version of “I'm curious”.
Hyouka has an episodic plot and it stays true to it till the end making it a better anime than Gosick in this aspect. Each mystery is in an ordinary setting and the reasoning is thoroughly explained and easily follow-able, which makes you feel you could have got it if you have tried a bit harder. Some of the mysteries are really easy while some are seriously interesting. Its a mixed bag basically. And so as the characters. While the main MC shows tremendous development. The supporting cast shows development in only select episodes and that is a tad irritating. That will be a factor in these episodic anime so it cant be helped. But my irritation is at how little we got to know of the female lead character, her life was mainly known in 2-3 episodes with the last episode giving the most exposition and there was really little to no development in her character. The way she was initially was the way she remained at the end of the anime. Except probably she fell in love. And that is another bone I have to pick. Its nice when hints of romance are shown but its really irritating when you don't have a season 2 and you cant quite pinpoint the romantic endings the anime as as there are only hints no definite answers. That s something I hate.
The last episode of the anime is deemed as a masterpiece by many, while I agree it is a masterpiece of situation animation, creating an open ended romantic story which originally was like a high school detective mystery doesn't earn brownie points. Yes there was a mystery even in the last episode but it was not really that relevant. The male MC still remained hesitant, while you can always find 101 reasons to support his actions, it doesn't mean you just end your anime like that. The female MC's life and wants are also hinted at but they are nearly not enough for a 22 episode anime. This would have been better off without the final two episodes. No romance is better than incomplete open ended romance in anime. Which means I have to deduct marks in coherence.
Well overall I cant say I didn't enjoy the anime, but I enjoyed Gosick more even if its a more flawed piece of work. Probably because it had a definite conclusion no matter how cliched it may be.
Final verdict:- Hyouka is a nice piece of animation. The moe artwork distracts a bit, and the incomplete romance leaves you wanting a non existent second season, but the mysteries are really interesting and are commonplace which makes you feel that incidents of this anime can happen around you and hence I give this one a thumbs up, not a big thumbs up but a decent one, i.e. it is a nice time killer. I would still prefer Gosick over this one though.



GO-SICK

GO-SICK REVIEW 


Anime:- Gosick
Genre:- Supernatural/Mystery/Romance
Number of Episodes:-24
Rating:- Animation and Artwork-7/10, Music:-7.5/10, Story-6/10,  Characters-5/10, Enjoyment-9/10(34.5/50)
To review Gosick is a really tough job. This anime has so many things going right for it and the fact that yet it fails to satisfy is what makes it so difficult. I would not go so far as to call this anime the anime of two halves but from the time the anime changed its ED it lost its charm. Let us talk about the positives first and then we will try to figure out where it went wrong.
The artwork is really nice for the setting in early 1900s. Its nice to see all those horse drawn carriages and the different dressing sense of people of that era. One thing striking is the Japanese still wore kimono in that era whereas the Europeans had a distinctly different dress sense. The animation is nice too, par for the course for a 2010 anime, nothing to spectacular but does its work.
The OP is really good, it has a light ring to it and sets you up nicely. But whats really good is the first ED. It has taken its place among my favourite EDs and perfectly matches with the tone of the show. Its really a shame that they had to change it and I didnt like the second ED as much. In anime music was nothing spectacular so I had to give an average score. The voice acting however was really average. It doesnt really bring out the characters and feels just vanishes into the countless ordinary voice acting of various anime you have watched. You dont remember much of the dialogues after you complete the anime, thats as much a fault of script as the voice acting.
The story had a tremendous amount of promise. It starts of episodic or 2-3 episodes together in a story. Initially it feels like a detective mystery anime. It would have been good if it had stayed so. But the author had other ideas, linking the female protagonist to a dark and oppressed past is okay if you have a good story to back it up. The author actually tried to. Linking the world wars to the main story line was a wonderful idea. Some of the cases had WW I linked with it too. An oppressed mother was also there to support the story to boot, with a travelling magician helping her and stuff. “The eternal love of the mother for her child with her making the final sacrifice to save her child” idea was there as well. There was a nice little romance between the main characters. The cases were presented in a way in which the viewer can solve them if he thought hard enough all the clues were there. So you could think with the show. I mean all this essentially is the formula for a really great show and for the firSt 13 episodes I could not understand how it can go wrong. Well, for the last 13 episodes too I could not understand how it went wrong but I will try my best to figure out.

The story lost its thrilling nature after episode 13. Episode 17 pissed me off. And yet there were flashes of previous brilliance scattered here and there in some of the episodes. The thing is there are two ways to make someone look intelligent. Make him/her unbelievably intelligent and get an almost equally intelligent antagonist, or make him/her decently intelligent and surround him/her with dumb characters. Sadly Gosick does the latter. The male protagonist is as dumb and cheesy as they come. The ending dialogue of the anime is as cheesy as they come. These were two big flaws in the anime. Then, trying to mix up supernatural and logic leads to disastrous effects most of the time. Gosick is a living proof. Also initially starting off with an episodic tone and trying to “increase” the number of episodes involved in those small stories is a nice idea but here they faltered somehow. They made terrible use of the characters they created. There is almost little to no character development of any of them, which results in little to no empathy at their deaths. The only good part was the mother-daughter bonding and the rest somehow left very little mark though all the ingredients were there. So in the end the problem with this one would be wasting the potential of a great cast of characters, losing the thrilling nature of the first half by trying too much which draws the viewer and cheesy script writing. Yes that should do it.
Well I wouldn't say I didn't enjoy the show but I hoped to enjoy it more.
Final Verdict:- Its a show that I would recommend if you like mystery which are solvable if you use your head, it wont mindfuck you but that's not a bad thing, also you might be left a little dissatisfied at the end with the show but you have to live with that. Its worth watching, its not a bad one.


CHARLOTTE

Charlotte review by Roopayan Ghosh


Charlotte- An incomprehensible potpourri of ideas or another of Maeda's masterpiece??

This isn't one of my normal reviews its more informal, there will be a tl;dr at the end though. 
SPOILERS may follow.


So when the show aired I heard a lot of opinions of the show, some people said it was brilliant while others said it was shit. I trusted the shiteportion of the crowd more because I personally knew their tastes and steered clear of it. But then I had to download the anime for somebody else and had it in my HDD, so I was like whats the big deal lets see this anime, lets see how bad it is.


Firstly the premise, the trailer of animax made me think its a superpower action supernatural anime, the protagonist was a retarded asshole and an anti-hero who fought against the good guys etc etc, like maybe Reversi in Bakuman/ Code Geass etc. After watching the first episode I was taken aback. It was nothing of that sort, rather it was more mellow and school life action romance ish. It was even funny at times. It wasn't dark, depressing and thought provoking as I thought it might have been.
Which incidentally is not something I hate, I always like this light hearted school anime with a little bit of romance and SoL in it. And unlike most of the people who were complaining about this region of the show, I actually liked it and probably would have ended up loving it if this continued for the entire season, but no Maeda had other ideas, he had to go back to his staple idea of deaths and making people cry.


However this death had a problem. The anime was too short for him. maeda generally requires an insane amount of time to build characters. he had that in Clannad so he could produce something like Afterstory, he has all the time he likes in VNs as well, but in 13 episode anime, his style fails completely. Sure he tried to create a nice happy character and killed it off to generate tears, but he was too early, it didn't have impact. I don't remember not crying in anime deaths, or something which I watched without batting an eye, but here I did, and I was surprised. Instantly it made me realize this show wasnt one of his good ones.


Then he did what he does best, showing how a loved one deals with the death of another one. He went to extremes here, but I don't really mind, but the lack of episodes showed here as well, while in his masterpiece afterstory he had 5-6 episodes to develop the pain and suffering and then bring it to a resolution, here he has one. And to combine all that emotion to one episode is just not possible. He tried his best but it didn't work out.


But the sad part he he didn't stop there, he got into the time travel business. While i wouldn't say he messed it up completely, but a feeling which Steins; gate took 20 episodes to build, cannot be built in 1 episode. he didnt set proper laws for time travel(which is very essential) and so this part of the anime falls below mediocrity. Also he put in an underwear shot which I found absolutely unnecessary(why would you strip an esper, duh? ) and some sudden invasion of new villains to drive the story. Then the protag does some stupid shit and a person dies again. This death was slightly more impactful since he had more episodes at his disposal, but by this time the anime was on its last lap so there was no time to let the effects of it sink inAbout the ending which people bash, i will not, because this wasn't an adventure anime. I am sure people wanted more stories, more interactions with the new challenges our protagonist would face but to be honest he was so Op at that time that it didn't matter.Well there were parts I actually liked as well. the protagonist's character development wasn't too shabby, though the female character development was a dirac delta function(search this term on wiki) and so was the romance. But maeda being maeda still gave me something to smile about in the romance. And then totally destroys the atmosphere by putting in cheezy ending line. "Our life starts from here". Seriously Maeda, that's the best you could come up with?? I put the screenshot I think should have ended it etc along with the pictures.
tl;dr:- I cant call it shit, I have seen worse anime than this and this is definitely better than your generic harems and esper stories like Tokyo ESP and stuff, but its definitely one of the worse Maeda works. he should stick to VN. the anime medium is too restrictive for him.


So ratings Art and Animation-7/10, Music-7/10, Story-3.5/10, characters-3.5/10, enjoyment-6/10(27/50) remember this is MAL scale and different from my previous scale of 7/10 as average.